Banks report wildly different emissions for similar loan books, but the cause is mostly what they count, not bad data. Two respondents argue for measured data over estimates, and for use cases a lender can verify.
Climate data now sits in loan files, investor reports and regulatory returns. Lenders use it to price green loans, track financed emissions and judge transition risk. Still, many borrowers never report their emissions, so lenders estimate much of the data. As a result, the question is not only how to collect more, but how far anyone can trust the climate data that firms collect.
We asked one question: how is your fintech helping customers or lenders measure climate or sustainability data, and how reliable is that data today? We wanted founders and product leads at green fintechs, ESG data providers and sustainability leads at banks and lenders. Specific use cases mattered more than general commentary. Two people answered in this round, and we used both. Neither works in ESG data or sustainable lending, so we’ve set their views against the evidence.
How reliable is climate data today?
The headline numbers look alarming. Four global banks of similar size reported financed emissions of 4, 19, 46 and 115 million tonnes of CO2e for 2024, a Bank of England staff blog post found. That is a spread of almost 30 times. However, the author traced most of the gap to which loans and activities each bank counted, not to poor climate data.
On a common boundary, estimates for UK banks from their own disclosures and from two data providers fell within about 10% of each other. Therefore, the bigger reliability problem is consistency of scope. Estimates still fill most gaps, though. Most borrowers do not disclose emissions, so banks often rely on sector averages instead of measured figures.
Pick use cases you can measure
Marc Pamatian is a finance and bookkeeping specialist and founder of Chief Bookkeeping Officer.
“How reliable ESG data is today depends heavily on the source and the method behind it. ESG factors are increasingly part of financial decisions, but much of the data still isn’t standardised, which makes comparisons hard. That matters most when businesses are trying to align their operations with sustainability goals or meet investors’ expectations. Demand for transparency is growing, but until reporting frameworks are applied consistently, ESG assessments will stay somewhat subjective.
Green fintechs and ESG data providers can help close those gaps by using technology to improve how data is collected and checked. For banks and lenders, focusing on specific use cases, such as energy efficiency upgrades or measured cuts in carbon emissions, gives more measurable results. The most valuable data doesn’t just track compliance; it shows real outcomes over time.”
Marc Pamatian, Founder, Chief Bookkeeping Officer
His best point is the narrow use case. A lender can check an energy efficiency loan against meter readings before and after, which makes its climate data far firmer than a company-wide estimate. His original answer suggested no globally accepted framework exists yet. In fact, 35 jurisdictions had adopted the ISSB standards by July 2026, S&P Global reports, so we’ve adjusted his wording to focus on consistent use. Still, his answer is general, and he describes no client or product of his own.
Check reported figures against real activity
Kuldeep Kundal is founder and CEO of CISIN, a technology services firm that builds custom software and data systems.
“Standardising climate data means moving beyond voluntary disclosures to automated data flows across a company’s systems, treating sustainability metrics with the same rigour as financial accounting. The main barrier to reliable ESG metrics isn’t a lack of information, but fragmented corporate systems. To fix that, firms need to bring together scattered sources, from ERP records to energy readings from connected devices, into one reporting layer.
Climate data is often weakened by heavy reliance on estimated benchmarks and manual entries. Technology can help by checking reported emissions against real operating activity, such as utility use and logistics routes. That creates an audit trail that can stand up to scrutiny, and once the metrics are built into everyday systems, they stop being a side compliance task and start driving efficiency.
Lenders increasingly want detailed, asset-level data rather than company-wide averages. That means capturing data where it’s created, whether from a smart meter on a factory floor or a digital shipping record. The industry is still early on, but automated, verifiable data pipelines are the most dependable route to the reliability green fintech needs. Reliability comes from integrating systems deeply, not from more complex reporting templates.”
Kuldeep Kundal, Founder and CEO, CISIN
His cross-check is the most practical idea here. Comparing reported emissions with utility bills or fuel use turns an estimate into something a lender can test. Also, bank transaction data, the same feeds behind open banking, already shows what a business spends on energy. His original answer called automated pipelines “the only way” to reliable climate data, which went too far, so we’ve softened it. We also found no study measuring his claim that lenders now demand asset-level data. CISIN builds systems rather than running ESG assessments, so this is design advice, not a case study.
Rules are shifting the data burden
Regulation will shape how much climate data lenders can get. In the UK, the government published final UK Sustainability Reporting Standards on 25 February 2026, CMS explains. They are voluntary for now. The FCA has proposed requiring listed companies to report against the climate standard from 1 January 2027.
The EU has gone the other way on scope. Its Omnibus I package, adopted on 24 February 2026, limits CSRD reporting to companies with more than 1,000 employees and over €450 million in turnover, Clifford Chance notes. It also caps what large firms can ask smaller suppliers for. As a result, lenders will see less reported climate data from small businesses, and measured sources become more valuable.
What works for lenders using climate data
The evidence points to a clear order of work. First, state which loans and activities your financed emissions cover, because boundary choice moves the total more than data quality does. Next, start with narrow use cases, such as energy efficiency loans, where lenders can measure results. Then check reported or estimated climate data against bills, meter readings or bank transactions, as Kundal suggests. Finally, record which figures are measured and which are estimated, so users can judge the confidence behind each number. Clear disclosure habits help in other areas too, as our roundup on beneficial ownership rules shows.
What to watch next
The FCA’s final rules on UK climate reporting, expected this autumn, will set the pace for listed borrowers’ climate data. Also watch how EU lenders cope with less supplier climate data under the new CSRD limits. In addition, more ISSB adoptions, and reversals such as Brazil’s move away from a mandate, will show how consistent global reporting becomes.
Above all, reliable climate data starts with being clear about what is counted and how. Lenders that publish their boundaries and test estimates against real activity will have numbers others can trust.
FintechBits covers payments, banking and fintech developments for readers in the US and UK. This article is for information only and is not financial or investment advice. Views expressed are those of the FintechBits editorial team.



